Dessert Island Dish

Desert island dishes is a difficult game for me to play. Choosing one dish over another feels like a minor indiscretion on my part. Surely it is a Sunday dinner with all the oozing gravy. But then what about my need for spice? Or my love of all things Italian? So a spicy tomato pasta it must be. With cheese. But then that leaves me without one of the main joys in life: roasted veg. And roast potatoes. Then there I am, back to square one. Tricky. Very tricky.

But dessert island dish is a much easier game. Banoffee pie wins. No hesitation, no question. Undisputed champion of the desserts.


This pud is a joy from beginning to end. It is ridiculously easy to make and ridiculously delicious to eat. Plus, it offers my very favourite ‘lick-the-bowl’ moment: crushed digestive and warm melted butter. Yes please.

If only I were on a desert island eating just this dessert! I would be very (round) happy girl. So that is next year’s holiday sorted then.





INGREDIENTS (serves 1-8, dependent upon self-control):

For the base
100g butter
250g digestive biscuits

For the middle
100g butter
100g dark brown soft sugar
397g tin of condensed milk

For the top
4 bananas
300ml double cream
70g good quality dark chocolate


First, prepare your tin. You want a 20cm round, loose-bottomed one ideally (although, 8 little, individual, loose-bottomed tins would also work), and you should grease it well on the bottom and sides.

On to the base. Crush your biscuits however you will (I like to throw them around the kitchen in their packet a bit, the bash them in a bowl with a rolling pin), until rubble-like but not too sandy.

Melt your butter (100g) then pour it over your biscuit crumbs and mix well.

Tip all your biscuit mix into your prepared tin. Now you need to press you crumb down to make it solid. You can do this two ways: either push it all down on the bottom, which will give you one really deep base (which is how I like mine) or else push it both on the bottom and up the sides, creating a biscuit crust all around the tin.

Whichever way you decide, put it the base into the fridge to solidify for at least 10 minutes.

Meanwhile, make your ‘offee’. Melt your butter (100g) and sugar (100g) together over a low to medium heat, stirring constantly, until the sugar has dissolved. Add the condensed milk, increase the heat, and bring the mix to a boil. Leave the caramel boil ferociously for at least one minute (anything less will mean that it will not set).

Once boiled, pour on top of your chilled base, then return the pie to the fridge, to set. Leave it in the fridge for at least one hour, but ideally until you are about ready to serve the pudding.

Once set, take the tin out of the fridge and carefully transfer the pie from the tin to a serving plate. (As the pie should be quite solid, this is easier than it sounds.)

Slice your bananas and arrange them on top of the caramel.

Whip the double cream up until it retains its shape, then spread this all over the banana layer.

Finally, grate chocolate all over the top of the pie.

You can either serve straight away, or return the completed pie to the fridge to wait until you are ready for it.


I made this pud as part of a meal for some friends that visited us. The main course that preceded it was mushroom, spinach and blue cheese pithivier with roasted new potatoes, corriander and cumin carrots and onion gravy. I didn’t manage to take too many photos as I was too busy being sociable (read: drinking red wine). But here are a few that I did manage…





Just let me know if you want the recipes for any of them!

Also, I would love to know your desert (or dessert) island dishes!


4 thoughts on “Dessert Island Dish

    • Hello!

      They are mushroom, spinach and blue cheese pithivier sort of things that I made up.

      For 4 you want about 500g puff-pastry (homemade or bought), 4 large field mushrooms, 250g spinach, and a bit of blue cheese (I used Saint Agur). Fry your mushrooms until soft, then leave to dry off as much as possible. Wilt the spinach then dry as much as possible. Make little stacks of spinach, cheese, mushroom, cheese. Cut 4 pastry circles about 1cm wider than the mushrooms, and place the mushroom stacks on top. Cut 4 larger discs of pastry and place them over the mushrooms stacks, pressing to get all the air out, then brush the edges with water and crimp together. Brush the pastry with an egg wash, then pop in the oven (about 200oC) for 15-20 minutes.

      Let me know if you try them!


    • Thank you!

      The carrots are really easy – just peel and chop carrots to desired size and spread on a baking tray; grind together 2 tsp cumin seeds and 1 tsp coriander seeds in a pestle and mortar and sprinkle over the carrots; drizzle over 2 tbsp honey and 1tbsp olive oil and mix everything together with your hands. Roast in the oven at 200oC for about 40 minutes, dependent upon size.

      I hope you have a go – let me know if you do!


I would love to hear what you think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s